In the wake of her passing, tributes have poured in from Virgin River’s cast and crew. Alexandra Breckenridge, who plays the show’s lead, Mel Monroe, took to social media to share a tearful message: “Annette wasn’t just our Hope — she was the heart of Virgin River. Her humor, kindness, and brilliance touched every one of us.” Breckenridge went on to describe O’Toole as a mentor and friend, someone who carried herself with both grace and grit — qualities she infused into her iconic role.

Martin Henderson, who stars as Jack Sheridan, echoed similar sentiments. “Working with Annette was one of the great privileges of my career,” he wrote. “She had a rare ability to make everyone feel seen and valued. The world feels a little dimmer without her.” The Netflix family, too, released an official statement, calling O’Toole “a radiant talent whose artistry and heart defined the soul of Virgin River.”

A Pillar of Virgin River

Since the series debuted in 2019, Annette O’Toole’s Hope McCrea became an integral part of the Virgin River universe. A fierce advocate for her tight-knit community, Hope represented the show’s moral compass — often meddling in others’ affairs with good intentions, yet always driven by love and loyalty. Her on-screen chemistry with Tim Matheson (Doc Mullins) brought humor and tenderness to the series, their dynamic reflecting a mature and complex love that resonated deeply with fans.

As the show progressed, O’Toole’s performance earned widespread acclaim. Viewers admired her nuanced portrayal of a woman balancing authority, vulnerability, and heart. Even when Hope faced tragedy — from health crises to emotional struggles — O’Toole delivered each scene with quiet power and authenticity. Her absence will not only be felt in the storylines ahead but in the very heartbeat of Virgin River itself.

The Cast’s Emotional Farewell

Following news of her passing, the Virgin River set turned into a space of remembrance and reflection. Patrick Sean Smith, the showrunner, revealed that the upcoming seventh season will pay tribute to O’Toole. “Annette’s spirit is woven into every frame of this show,” Smith shared. “We intend to honor her with the love and respect she deserves. The cast and crew are united in grief but also in gratitude for the time we had with her.”

Breckenridge, Henderson, and Matheson reportedly gathered with other co-stars for a private memorial near the filming location in British Columbia, where Virgin River’s idyllic landscapes have long mirrored the show’s emotional depth. On social media, fans from around the world shared their condolences, many expressing how Hope McCrea had inspired them to stay strong, kind, and compassionate — much like O’Toole herself.

A Legacy That Transcends Virgin River

Annette O’Toole’s career spanned over five decades, encompassing television, film, and music. From her early roles in classics like Superman III and 48 Hrs. to her critically acclaimed work in Smallville and Virgin River, O’Toole consistently brought authenticity and emotional truth to every performance. Her ability to shift effortlessly between drama and comedy made her a rare talent in Hollywood.

Beyond her acting, O’Toole was also a gifted songwriter and singer. Fans may recall that she co-wrote “A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow” — the Oscar-nominated song from A Mighty Wind — with her husband, Michael McKean. Together, they embodied creativity and partnership both on and off screen.

Sullivan’s Crossing: A Spiritual Successor

Interestingly, as Virgin River fans mourn the loss of O’Toole, another series based on Robyn Carr’s novels — Sullivan’s Crossing — has surged in popularity on Netflix. The show, led by Morgan Kohan and Chad Michael Murray, tells the story of a neurosurgeon returning to her hometown after personal turmoil — echoing the themes of healing, love, and renewal that Virgin River captured so beautifully.

Both series share Carr’s signature storytelling style — small-town settings, deep emotional arcs, and the transformative power of community. Showrunner Roma Roth, who also serves as executive producer on Virgin River, explained that Sullivan’s Crossing continues the spirit of hope and connection that O’Toole championed through her portrayal of Mayor McCrea.